Give Rishi Sunak a little credit for hitting his inflation target – but not a lot

In January the Prime Minister outlined his five priorities for 2023. The first pledge was to “halve inflation this year to ease the cost of living and give people financial security.” The other targets are more challenging, but this one at least has now been met.

This is because the CPI measure of inflation fell to 4.6 per cent in October, which was less than half the January figure of 10.1 per cent (as well as the November 2022 figure of 10.7 per cent, which was the latest available data when the PM spoke).

Nonetheless, the Prime Minister will struggle to claim any credit. The drop in inflation (both in the UK and elsewhere) mainly reflects the tightening in monetary policy, the global economic slowdown, and the decline in commodity prices, rather than anything the government has done. Managing inflation is, in any case, the responsibility of the Bank of England.

Indeed, inflation was already widely expected to halve over the course of the year. Back in January the average forecast for the fourth quarter of 2023 in the Treasury’s poll of independent forecasters was 5 per cent, and the average of new forecasts (those made in the previous three months) was down to 4.5 per cent. It is therefore tempting to say that the target would probably have been met anyway.

But I think that would be harsh. For a start, this was not a done deal. At various times during the year many commentators have doubted that the target would still be met, notably after disappointing data for September (“Sticky UK inflation puts Rishi Sunak’s target in jeopardy”).

Ministers can also still claim that inflation would have been slower to fall if the Prime Minister and Chancellor had not taken ‘tough decisions’ on fiscal policy, by holding the line on public sector pay and resisting calls for tax cuts, while encouraging people back to work.

What’s more, inflation has more than halved without the recession that many feared. At the start of the year the UK economy was expected to shrink by around 1 per cent in 2023 (see the Treasury poll again). Now it looks set to expand by around 0.5 per cent. If you combine the first and second pledges – halving inflation while still growing the economy – the achievement looks a little better.

Finally, it seems churlish for opposition politicians who blamed the Tories for the rise in inflation in 2022 to deny them any credit for the fall in inflation in 2023. Surely, they can’t have it both ways?

Politics aside, the latest fall in inflation is, of course, unambiguously good news. The sharp fall between September (6.7 per cent) and October (4.6 per cent) was mainly due to the lowering of the Ofgem cap on domestic energy bills. But other components were also subdued, meaning overall inflation was lower than expected.

There are plenty of reasons to expect inflation to continue falling. Producer price inflation has dropped sharply, notably in the food sector, and petrol prices are now falling again. UK inflation appears to be following US inflation down with a lag of around six months. Less positively, money and credit growth have collapsed, and economic activity is now flatlining.

Inflation is therefore back on track to return to the Bank of England’s 2 per cent target early next year, which would be much sooner than most people had expected. This should slam the door on any further increases in interest rates and bring forward the timing of the first cut.

Hitting the Prime Minister’s inflation target also removes one obstacle to tax cuts in the Autumn Statement (although any big changes in personal taxes will presumably be held back until next year). Combined with a further recovery in real wages, this should mean that the UK economy continues to dodge the long-feared recession.

In short, the pledge to halve inflation was always little more than a piece of political theatre. But it is clearly better to have hit this target than to have missed it. That at least is worth a cheer.

This article was first published by CapX on 15 November 2023

One thought on “Give Rishi Sunak a little credit for hitting his inflation target – but not a lot

  1. Yes, a soon to be 3trn government debt and another 2trn on top for decarbonisation will not be supported by those internationally concerned about ever seeing all their money again if there is significant risk of a run on sterling. Printing money does not help in this regard.

    Dropping over 2% of global share of gdp every decade for eighty years with now less than 2.8% to go means an economic cross roads perhaps well within a decade or so anyway.

    So not a penny of exchequer money is needed if UK private investment can successfully access Mark Carne’s COP26 GFANZ 132trns of green international bonds globally searching for a safe payback.

    So for a good start, how about placing nearly all the unique solely to UK domestic secondary legislation, over 6000 unaffordable new laws, which no one else in the EU or the rest of the globe has, immediately on the shelf as guide line only. The infrastructure unit build prices currently around 10 to 20 times more than any other nation on earth would plummet overnight to match global average again.

    Pronto.

    Like

Leave a reply to Richard Robinson Cancel reply