Jeremy Hunt’s tightrope act could see the economy take a tumble

It’s usual for some of the contents of a Budget to leak out before the official announcement. This time, though, we already have a very clear idea of what’s coming on Thursday. The Prime Minister and Chancellor, and their backroom teams, have worked hard to prepare us for ‘difficult decisions’.

The good news is that we can expect more help for the most vulnerable households, including a large increase in the national minimum wage. Working-age benefits and the state pension are both now likely to be raised in line with inflation, and there will be another round of cost-of-living support payments.

There should also be some more clarity about the targeted help with energy bills that will replace the universal Energy Price Guarantee in April.

The bad news is that there will also be around £25 billion of tax increases and £35 billion in spending cuts in order to plug a £60 billion ‘black hole’ in the public finances. Many people, including many economists, are rightly worried that these measures could drag the UK into a far deeper recession, as well as undermine public services.

In my view, Jeremy Hunt is taking an unnecessary risk here. The £60 billion estimate for the ‘black hole’ is really just guesswork. It is based on five-year forecasts for growth and inflation which we know will be wrong. It also depends on the Chancellor’s own choice of fiscal rules, and on the amount of ‘headroom’ that the Treasury wants to create for itself.

Some argue that Sunak and Hunt must be now more cautious in order to restore credibility lost by Truss and Kwarteng and to prevent further big increases in interest rates. But even if you buy this narrative, it is surely sufficient to cancel the measures that unsettled the financial markets, rather than double-down. I have yet to meet any investors who are screaming for taxes to be hiked and spending slashed as the UK economy slides into recession.

Despite this, I also try to be positive. The Chancellor is about to take an unnecessary risk, but it could be minimised.

This is mainly about timing. The bulk of the increases in personal taxes are likely to take the form of freezes in a wide range of allowances, which determine the thresholds at which tax rates go up. These ‘stealth tax’ increases will gradually raise more revenue for the Treasury as more people are dragged into higher rate bands over the next five years. But crucially, they will have little impact on the amount of tax that households pay now.

Instead, any immediate increases in taxes are likely to be targeted at those who can (perhaps) afford them the most. For example, the highest earners could face a reduction in the threshold at which they pay the 45p upper rate of income tax. Energy companies will surely be hit by more ‘windfall taxes’.

The timing point also applies to public spending. Already tight departmental budgets will remain tighter for longer, but there will not necessarily be any major cuts now.

In short, my fear is that the pendulum is swinging too far from the pro-growth plans of Truss and Kwarteng, back to self-defeating orthodoxy and austerity, at a time when the economy needs all the support it can get. My hope is that the Treasury is smarter than that.

This article was first published in the Independent on 15 November 2022

2 thoughts on “Jeremy Hunt’s tightrope act could see the economy take a tumble

  1. David Smith’s 13 November Sunday Times article attributed the sudden discovery of a supposed fiscal black hole after the Truss/Kwarteng mini-budget to two pre-existing trends not accounted for previously, viz. much higher inflation which could endure for longer, and higher interest rates and bond yields generally reflecting this and corresponding more assertive central bank rate hikes. The market flurry after the mini-budget was speculators seeing an open goal and doing what they are employed to do, given the chronic capital inflow needed to UK BoP current a/c deficits going back decades and its reliance on foreign gilts purchases. That UK premium has since for practical purposes gone but with yields higher as they are elsewhere and nothing to do with the mini-budget. So we are were we would have been anyway. But these numbers will drop as recession takes hold and unless official forecasts include this, as private sector internal business and investment planning forecasts would, a phantom fiscal black hole will be perpetuated, and wrong policy actions will make the recession worse. An end to the Ukraine war will sharply cut inflation worries and the supposed black hole ; and/or success in China with Covid ditto: still two known unknowns , but more likely than not in the UK fiscal near term planning period.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s